Evaluation and Comparison Biases

“Comparison is the thief of joy.” — Theodore Roosevelt

Evaluation and comparison biases are types of cognitive biases that affect the way we perceive and evaluate information.

In this list, we will explore various examples of these biases and how they can impact our decision-making processes.

From the anchoring bias to the Von Restorff effect, each of these biases can have a significant impact on the way we perceive and evaluate information.

By understanding these biases, we can become better critical thinkers and make more informed decisions.

What are Evaluation and Comparison Biases?

Evaluation and comparison biases refer to the cognitive and psychological tendencies that affect our ability to accurately evaluate and compare different options, choices, or situations.

These biases can influence how we perceive, interpret, and make judgments about information, leading us to make errors in reasoning, decision-making, and problem-solving.

Examples of evaluation and comparison biases include anchoring bias, framing effect, confirmation bias, and overconfidence effect.

Evaluation and Comparison Biases

Here are common evaluation and comparison biases:

Anchoring bias: This is the tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information encountered when making decisions. To avoid this, try to keep an open mind and gather as much information as possible before making a decision.
Endowment effect: This is the tendency to overvalue something simply because you own it. To avoid this bias, try to objectively assess the value of something before factoring in the fact that you own it.
False uniqueness effect: This is the tendency to overestimate the extent to which our talents, abilities, and opinions are unique. To avoid this bias, try to consider the perspectives and experiences of others and recognize that you are not the only person who possesses certain talents or views.
Halo effect: This is the tendency to let one positive trait influence how we perceive someone’s overall character or abilities. To avoid this bias, try to consider someone’s individual traits separately and objectively.
Social comparison bias: This is the tendency to evaluate ourselves based on how we compare to others rather than our own personal standards. To avoid this bias, try to focus on your own goals and achievements rather than constantly comparing yourself to others.
Status quo bias: This is the tendency to prefer things to stay the way they are rather than change. To avoid this bias, try to consider the potential benefits of change and objectively evaluate the status quo.
Telescoping effect: This is the tendency to perceive recent events as occurring further in the past than they actually did and older events as occurring more recently than they actually did. To avoid this bias, try to keep a record of events to help maintain a more accurate timeline.
Von Restorff effect: This is the tendency to remember unusual or distinct items more easily than common items. To avoid this bias, try to focus on the information as a whole and avoid letting the most memorable information overly influence your decision-making process.

Examples of How To Use the Evaluation and Comparison Biases to Think Better

Here are examples of how knowing the evaluation and comparison biases can help you think better:

Anchoring Bias: When negotiating a salary, research the industry standard to avoid accepting an offer that is lower than your worth based on an initial, arbitrary number. An example of Anchoring Bias is when a customer sees a high-priced item first, and then when they see lower-priced items, they view them as a good deal even if they are still expensive. For instance, a customer who walks into a store and sees a suit priced at $1000 may believe it is too expensive, but if they see a suit priced at $500 next, they may believe it is a great deal, even though it is still expensive.
Endowment Effect: When selling a used item, try to separate your emotional attachment and consider the actual value of the item to avoid setting an unreasonably high price. The endowment effect is the tendency for people to value an object or asset more highly simply because they own it. For example, a person who has owned a car for many years may overvalue it when trying to sell it because they have become attached to it and feel a sense of ownership. Similarly, a person may be willing to pay more for an item at an auction if they are the current high bidder because they feel a sense of ownership over the item. This bias can lead people to make irrational or suboptimal decisions when it comes to selling or trading their possessions.
False Uniqueness Effect: When presenting an idea to a group, avoid assuming that your idea is inherently better than others and instead consider the potential strengths and weaknesses of all ideas presented. The false uniqueness effect is a tendency to believe that our own positive traits and abilities are unique and uncommon, while negative traits are more common among others. An example of this could be a student who performs well on a test and believes that their success is due to their exceptional intelligence, while attributing the success of others to factors such as luck or cheating. This bias can lead to overconfidence and a lack of effort to improve oneself, as well as a negative view of others who may have similar abilities.
Halo Effect: When evaluating a person’s performance, avoid allowing a single strength or weakness to influence your overall perception of their abilities. An example of the halo effect is when a person assumes that a celebrity or public figure is good at everything simply because they are popular and well-known, without objectively evaluating their individual skills or abilities in specific areas.
Social Comparison Bias: When setting personal goals, avoid comparing yourself to others and instead focus on your own progress and improvement. An example of social comparison bias could be when a person compares their job, income, or lifestyle to those of their friends or peers on social media. This can lead to feelings of inadequacy or low self-esteem if they perceive themselves as falling short in comparison to others. It can also lead to a distorted view of reality if people only present their best selves on social media, leading to unrealistic expectations and comparisons. To avoid this bias, one could focus on their own progress and personal goals rather than comparing themselves to others.
Status Quo Bias: When considering making a change, avoid defaulting to the current situation and instead consider the potential benefits and drawbacks of the alternatives. An example of Status Quo Bias is when a company decides to continue using a particular software system despite the existence of newer and more efficient alternatives, simply because they are familiar with the current system and don’t want to go through the effort of changing.
Telescoping Effect: When reflecting on past events, avoid allowing the passage of time to distort your memory and instead try to recall the details as accurately as possible. The telescoping effect refers to the tendency of people to remember the timing of past events as occurring more recently than they actually did. For example, someone may recall an event that took place five years ago and remember it as having occurred just two years ago. This bias can impact decision-making in situations where accurate timing is important, such as in legal or medical cases. It can also impact our perception of time in our personal lives, leading us to believe that certain events or trends occurred more recently than they actually did.
Von Restorff Effect: When designing a presentation, consider using visual or auditory cues to make certain information stand out and be more memorable to the audience. An example of the Von Restorff effect is when a company launches a new product and uses a unique and attention-grabbing packaging design to make the product stand out on the shelves compared to its competitors. This increases the product’s memorability and perceived value, potentially leading to higher sales.

Know Your Evaluation and Comparison Biases to Think Better

Evaluation and comparison biases can heavily influence our decision making, often leading us to make choices that are not necessarily in our best interest.

By being aware of these biases and actively working to overcome them, we can become better critical thinkers and make more informed decisions.

Whether in our personal lives or in the workplace, understanding these biases can ultimately lead to more positive outcomes and greater success.

Big List of Biases
Attention Biases
Attitude and Belief Biases
Communication Biases
Cultural Biases
Decision-Making Biases
Emotional Biases
Scotoma: Why You Can’t See What’s Right in Front of You
How Labeling Others Distorts Your Thinking
How To Improve Your Critical Thinking
How To Practice Precision Questions and Answers