• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer

Sources of Insight

Better Insights. Better Results.

  • Help Me With
    • Future Self
    • Personal Development
    • Personal Effectiveness
    • Thinking Skills
    • Happiness
    • All Topics –>
  • Frameworks
  • Resources
  • Books & Courses
  • About
  • Contact

Half a Loaf Over Half a Baby

by JD

There are two different kinds of compromises in decision making.  One compromise results in a decision that gets you towards the solution.  The other compromise results in a decision that is worse than where you started from. 

In The Essential Drucker: The Best of Sixty Years of Peter Drucker’s Essential Writings on Management, Peter Drucker illustrates these two distinct compromise types.

Key Take Aways

Here are my key take aways:

  • Half a loaf is better than no bread.
  • Half a baby is worse than none.

I think metaphors are great for illustrating points.  I think these metaphors are easy to relate to and will come in handy at work.

Half a Baby is Worse Than None

Go for half a loaf, and a whole baby.  Drucker writes:

“For there are two different kinds of compromise.  One kind is expressed in the old proverb, Half a loaf is better than no bread.  The other kind is expressed in the story of the judgment of Solomon, which was clearly based on the realization that half a baby is worse than no baby at all.  In the first instance, the boundary conditions are still satisfied.  The purpose of bread is to provide food, and half a loaf is still food.  Half a baby, however does not satisfy the boundary conditions.  For half a baby is not half of a living and growing child.  It is a corpse in two pieces.”

You Might Also Like

  • Boundary Conditions for Effective Decisions
Category: Book Nuggets, Business Effectiveness, Business Skills, Decision-Making, Effectiveness, Personal EffectivenessTag: Books, Business, Decision-Making, Effectiveness

About JD

Previous Post:Action Commitments
Next Post:First Figure Out What the Right Thing to Do IsFirst Figure Out the Right Thing

Sidebar

About the Author

JD

Hi, I'm J.D. Meier.
I've spent 25 years studying what helps people perform at their best in work and in life.
Join me on a quest to unleash your greatest potential.
Learn more...

The Shop

Curated books, tools, and programs I trust most to help you grow your greatness.
Browse the Shop

Popular Articles

7 Happiness Principles
25 Inspirational Movies
50 Life Hacks for Your Future Self
101 of the Greatest Insights and Actions
101 Questions that Empower You
How To Get Whatever You Want
How To Think Like Bill Gates
Lessons Learned from Bruce Lee
The Exponential Results Formula
You 2.0

My Best-Selling Book

This is the book that changes lives ...

Better Insights, Better Results!

Unleash your greatest potential! Better insights, better results! Learn proven practices for mind, body, emotions, career, finance, relationships, spirituality, and fun.

Growth. Resilience. Strength.

Learn mindsets, skillsets and toolsets to respond to change, built your resilience and grow your strengths..

Stand on the Shoulders of Giants!

Learn wisdom of the ages and modern sages through great books, great people, and great quotes.

Topics

  • All Topics
  • Personal Development
  • Future Self
  • Emotional Intelligence
  • Leadership
  • Personal Effectiveness
  • Productivity
  • Mental Health

The Shop

  • The Leadership Shop
  • The Personal Development Shop
  • The Gift Guide
  • Best Books I Recommend

Features

  • Featured Guests
  • Book Summaries
  • Great Lessons
  • Great Quotes
  • How Tos
  • Lists
  • All Resources

My Other Sites

  • JD Meier.com
  • Getting Results.com

Copyright © 2026 · Sources of Insight · All Rights Reserved